Boys will be boys & girls will be boys

by | Apr 19, 2012 | Feminism | 8 comments

Someone asked me, “Will you still consider yourself to be a part of the LGBT community after your transition?” I hesitated; I hadn’t thought about that. Having identified as a lesbian for most my life,seeing myself as LGBT, and having others view me in this way was almost habit, it was a part of me. But changing gender… Do I identify as male and disregard my transsexuality? Do I identify as male and identify as straight? Do I reject my connection with the LGBT community and find community with cisgender, heterosexual men?

There’s a lot to think about once you’ve completed gender reassignment, or when you are happy with the way you are, whatever stage you’re at. Do you let your appearance dictate the way you are perceived, or are you proud of where you came from, what you body has been through?

I don’t think I could ever neglect a part of me.

I hear of some bio-females going through gender reassignment after being very unhappy most their life, struggling with a lesbian label, and being ‘different’. But once their transition is complete, and they ‘pass’, they let go of all links to LGBT labels. They let go of their foundations. They fade into the crowd of misogynistic men, objectifying women, and belittling gay men. It’s almost like they forgot what they grew up in, what they went through to get to where they were. I see it as such an advantage, being able to be on both sides of the coin. I understand what it is like to be oppressed as a woman, and I will never forget that. I’ll hold onto that even though I call myself a man, and even though I look like a man, I will continue to be a feminist. And I know there’s a stigma surrounding men being feminists. Some say that men will never know how it feels to be a woman, and can’t ever call themselves feminists. I guess some men don’t really want to know, or just don’t see a reason as to why being a woman is different in the first place. In my opinion, transmen make better feminists, well, they could make the better feminists, if they realised that they have such a unique perspective.

Saying this, I understand that being a woman, you are subjugated, there’s no doubt about it, that’s just the way it is. Men dominate. And being a gay woman, part of that minority, you’ve got even less say. And when a bio-female transitions, they’re suddenly read as a male, and they see how they are treated differently, they feel that being a man has this sense of authority. They can act and behave in ways they couldn’t before and get away with it, because they are a man. And it’s got to be empowering for some people. The oppression is liberated, you don’t face that sexism any longer. But chances are that you might become a pretty misogynist man.

Transmen start acting like ‘real’ men so they can more convincingly ‘pass’ as male. And it works! Making sure you are the ‘alpha male’, dominating most situations, and throwing around sexist behaviour, it’s ‘the way men are’. From a young age, we are ‘taught’ to be boys or girls, our behaviour is moderated by parents, extended family and even teachers. If a little boy starts touching himself or runs around naked, we laugh, and say ‘boys will be boys’ and pull his trousers back up. He is just a child. If a little girl exposes herself in public, there are wide eyes and a hushed telling off, hoping no one else saw. She is just a child too, but it’s more acceptable for boys to be mischievous, and immature. The same way in which a man in a business environment, climbing the corporate ladder, will know what he wants, and will get it, with a ruthless approach, every man for himself. He’s praised for being so motivated and dedicated to getting to the top. A woman in the same situation will be seen as aggressive, and her behaviour will be seen as negative. I watch The Apprentice (BBC, UK TV series) and when I see male contestants admired by the judges, I think, if one of the female contestants had the same goals, orders, and actions, she would be treated totally differently.

Everyone has been ‘taught’ to accept and understand that these traits – aggression, immaturity, sexism – are a part of being male. You can’t change it. That’s just the way men are.

I just don’t understand why, when transmen have this advantage of understanding what it’s like to be oppressed by patriarchy, and disempowered by a misogynist culture, they would want to act like a ‘real’ man. It’s almost hypocritical. They’re in a better position to set an example to other men. There are such blatant differences between the sexes, and if we’re going to play up to these gender roles and stereotypes, then the difference will always exist, more obvious than ever.

Take a look at “Girls will be boys“, for a tongue-in-cheek, visual representation of what this post has been about.

Written By Sabah Choudrey

About the Author: Sabah Choudrey

Sabah Choudrey is a renowned consultant, writer, and speaker. With a background in public speaking, writing, and therapy, Sabah is dedicated to advocating for mental health and LGBTQ+ rights. Their work has inspired many to embrace their identities and live authentically.

Related Posts

Checking my Privilege

Checking my Privilege

I am always saying that we need to think about the ways in which we are oppressive and the ways in which we are oppressed. I constantly talk about intersectional feminism, power dynamics, and positions of the oppressor. I speak about these mechanisms around me. I am...

read more
Reclaim The Night, Brighton, 2012

Reclaim The Night, Brighton, 2012

On Saturday 17th November, I marched, yelled, and spoke at Reclaim the Night, Brighton. I’ve have only been to one or two marches, but this was one of a kind, and truly special to me. For one, I actually gave a shit about the cause; to end male violence against women....

read more

8 Comments

  1. iamacallboy

    I love this post.

    Recently, I found a YouTube channel of a transgendered female-to-male person chronicling his journey of transitioning. I love learning the perspective of a transgendred because they get to see through the eyes of both sexes.

    I think you’re doing a noble thing by trying to maintain who you are as a person through the transition. You might be the incorrect sex but you’re still the same person after you get it corrected. Stay strong!

    <3

    Reply
    • Smash Brown

      Thank you.
      Yeah it’s really something.

      Reply
  2. pinkagendist

    Gay men make good feminists too! I’ve been a Simone de Beauvoir feminist since adolescence.

    Reply
  3. Tam

    I’ve been struggling with the same “identity” issue and agree with you – trying to suppress where you came from in the name of fitting into some ideal of what a “man” is supposed to be seems pointless and doomed to fail. Hiding who I was, to me, implies it’s something to be ashamed of and removed from polite conversation. I’m still struggling with “passing” and “stealth” and how these intersect with tensions between authenticity and personal safety. A future blog on this is still churning around in my head. :)

    Reply
    • Smash Brown

      I look forward to reading it. Hope you manage to resolve some tension in doing so.

      Reply
  4. transfabulous

    I love this post, you have pretty much said my exact thoughts.

    One of the things I find most challenging about being a trans man is the expectations to become that alpha male, and not being considered enough of a man to actually transition to one if I don’t. And that pressure actually comes from the trans-masculine community as much as it does from everywhere else, if not more.

    Reply
    • Smash Brown

      You’re totally right, as if we have to assert our masculinity, compensate almost.
      Thanks for your comment.

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.